by Phil McNulty – Chief Football Writer at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium
In a bold assertion that has put both himself and Tottenham Hotspur firmly in the spotlight, Ange Postecoglou claimed that he “always” clinches a trophy in his second season at the helm. This ambitious declaration certainly raised eyebrows given that Spurs haven’t lifted silverware since their League Cup victory back in 2008 with Juande Ramos. Yet, Postecoglou was simply reflecting on his impressive managerial record.
The Australian’s pursuit to fulfill this ambitious promise took a major leap forward with a well-earned 2-1 victory against Manchester City, securing a Carabao Cup quarter-final showdown against none other than Manchester United.
Historically, Postecoglou has delivered, having secured the Australian title with South Melbourne and Brisbane Roar, the Japanese League with Yokohama F. Marinos, and the Asian Cup triumph with Australia in 2015—just two years into his managerial role. His tenure at Celtic also saw him clinch the Scottish Premiership in both seasons, underscoring a brilliant track record.
It must be noted, however, that while Postecoglou has enjoyed success, he wasn’t spared from failure in some past roles, notably during his brief stints at Panachaiki and Whittlesea Zebras where he did not complete two seasons. Unlike his predecessors who included Andre Villas-Boas, Tim Sherwood, and Antonio Conte, Postecoglou can at least take comfort in having a second season to stamp his authority at Spurs.
The pressure was palpable as his predecessors didn’t survive long enough to see their ambitions fulfilled, particularly notable was Mourinho’s dismissal just days before the 2021 Carabao Cup final. This context explains the cautious skepticism toward Postecoglou’s inflated confidence.
Yet, after a shaky start to the season, which saw his side drop points in high-profile games against Brighton and Crystal Palace, the win over City was more than a relief; it was a statement of intent. Had Spurs succumbed to City, it would have ignited criticism not regarding Postecoglou’s future but about the viability of his relentless attacking style amid concerns over consistency.
Against a City side missing key players like Erling Haaland, Spurs showcased their flair. Timo Werner steered them in front early on with a powerful strike—his first goal of the season—igniting support from the stands, his exuberant celebration highlighting his importance to the squad despite previous struggles in front of goal. The ironic chant of “Timo Werner – he scores when he wants” echoed in the stadium, embodying the good-humored spirit of the fans.
Spurs continued to press and it was Pape Matar Sarr who doubled their lead, displaying their attacking prowess. Even when Matheus Nunes pulled one back for City before half-time, Postecoglou’s men held firm, creating better chances and leaning on resilience, notably when Yves Bissouma cleared a late threat off the line.
The victory was no more than Spurs deserved; a late equalizer for City would have felt like robbery considering Spurs’ dominance throughout the match. This marked their sixth win in eight games at their magnificent home ground, a consistent campaign that hints at a resurgence.
Postecoglou, who has experienced the emotional rollercoaster of Premier League football, appears to have silenced some critics, at least for now. However, the challenge will be maintaining this performance level against other title contenders like Manchester United and navigating the demands of both the FA Cup and Europa League.
If this spirited display is a foretaste of what’s to come, Postecoglou’s ambitions for silverware could eventually become a palpable reality. The key will be finding that consistent Spurs ethos that was so evident against Manchester City, and building on this encouraging momentum.