Key information
- Western European countries are increasingly liberalizing the possibilities for assisted dying.
- Concerns exist about the potential harm caused to vulnerable people due to the relaxation of laws.
- Access to assisted dying varies between countries, with some focusing on terminal illnesses and others on unbearable suffering.
The UK's recent decision to consider legalizing assisted dying reflects a wider trend in Europe. Western European countries are increasingly moving toward liberalizing end-of-life options, including euthanasia and assisted suicide. This trend is evident in countries such as Austria, Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Spain and Switzerland, where various forms of assisted dying are already legal. Experts believe this development is inevitable, especially in Western and Northern Europe.
However, concerns exist about the potential unintended consequences of these increasingly lenient laws. Critics argue that existing regulations can be extended beyond their intended scope, potentially leading to harm, particularly for vulnerable people. Incidents in Switzerland with suicide capsules and in the Netherlands where young people suffering from mental disorders legally ended their lives are sounding the alarm. Despite attempts to implement strict criteria, the expansion of assisted dying remains a persistent concern.
Legislative progress and setbacks
The UK's journey towards legalizing assisted dying has been marked by both progress and setbacks. The recent vote highlights society's evolving views on end-of-life choices. Yet political landscapes play a crucial role in the trajectory of such legislation. Left-wing governments or parliaments are generally more receptive to proposals for assisted dying, while conservatives often oppose them.
The success of similar initiatives depends heavily on the political climate and public discourse. In Ireland, the influence of the Catholic Church has historically hampered progress on assisted dying, but recent developments suggest a change in attitude. Similarly, in France, legislative discussions were interrupted by political instability.
Country-specific approaches
Access to assisted dying varies between countries, with some requiring terminal illnesses while others focus on unbearable suffering, including psychological distress. Germany presents a unique case where assisted dying is technically illegal but decriminalized by the Federal Constitutional Court.
Central and Eastern Europe remains relatively slow to adopt assisted dying, influenced by religious and cultural factors. In Serbia, for example, the public is increasingly supportive of legalization, but the Orthodox Church opposes it. However, experts believe that once a few countries in this region legalize assisted dying, others will likely follow.
If you want access to all articles, subscribe here!
