Twenty-one months after the crash, the trial of Pierre Palmade opened Wednesday in Melun for the serious road accident he caused in Seine-et-Marne under the influence of narcotics, leading to the fall ultra-publicized story of a popular comedian stuck in his drug addiction.
The hearing started directly with a request from the accident victims’ lawyer, according to BFMTV. Me Moura Battikh discusses the status of the fetus: “Mila was six months pregnant. We know today that this child, Solin since that is the name chosen by his parents, was viable at the time of the accident.“, reports the lawyer. “Viability is 22 weeks and 500 grams, according to WHO criteria. Mila was 27 weeks and weighing 1,080 grams.“
After the cesarean section, doctors did not notice any movement or breathing. In legal terms, the child is born viable, but not alive. Symbolically, the president of the court asks Pierre Palmade: “Do you agree to be tried for manslaughter?“, to which the comedian replied:”Non“, at the helm, before returning to his place, his gaze still as haggard, report our colleagues from BFMTV.
Entering the court through a back door to escape the swarm of cameras, Pierre Palmade is sitting on the dock between his lawyers, pale complexion, sunken face, staring into space, wearing a black jacket over a white shirt . Called to the stand at the opening of the hearing before the criminal court, he stated his identity in a small voice. The comedian will “probably not” speak today, declared his lawyer Mourad Battikh upon his arrival.
On February 10, 2023 at the end of the day, the man of theater and television took the wheel to go shopping, after several days of partying and unbridled drug consumption. On a road in the south of the department, his car collided with a vehicle coming in front. In addition to the then 54-year-old actor, the accident left three seriously injured from the same family: a 38-year-old man, his six-year-old son and his 27-year-old sister-in-law, who lost her baby after the impact. ‘she was waiting.
One road accident among the 52,000 recorded in mainland France that year. But due to the notoriety of the accused, this collision will explode into a media storm of rare intensity. Throughout the cascade of revelations about the lifestyle and addictions of this drifting artist, the general public discovers with astonishment the dark side of a popular comedian, although a little out of fashion, who has been staging since 30 years of his struggle against his existential terrors.
After a long year of judicial investigation, the investigating judge sent Pierre Palmade back to the Melun Criminal Court at the end of May on the sole charge of involuntary injuries, aggravated by the use of drugs. She did not retain the qualification of involuntary homicide, which the prosecution had requested for the loss of the fetus, considering that this thorny question at the confluence of bioethics and law deserved a “debate before the trial court”.
Legal debates
“This choice of the investigating magistrate is, in my opinion, highly contested and questionable, it must therefore be discussed”declared the lawyer for the three victims of the accident, Me Mourad Battikh, at the start of the hearing.
Following the accident, the baby was urgently extracted by cesarean section from his mother’s womb at six months of pregnancy, but declared dead after 32 minutes of resuscitation, without having given any sign of extra-uterine life. However, according to consistent case law from the Court of Cassation which has ruled on similar cases of road accidents, a child who is not born alive does not exist as a legal person.
“In this case, everyone agrees to challenge absurd case law”estimated Mr. Battikh. At the end of the day in February 2023, Pierre Palmade had a large quantity of cocaine and 3MMC (a synthetic drug) in his blood when he got behind the wheel with two “bringue” companions, who were not prosecuted .
His heyday of the 1990s-2000s behind him, heavily in debt, the comedian is so mired in his drug addiction that he is no longer able to work.
On the departmental 372 near Villiers-en-Bière, the Peugeot 3008 of its production company veered into the oncoming traffic lane and collided head-on with the Renault Mégane of the Y. family, which was arriving in the opposite direction.
The injured family members are still suffering the physical and psychological after-effects of the accident.
Pierre Palmade is a repeat offender due to a conviction in 2019 for drug use. He faces a sentence of fourteen years’ imprisonment and a fine of 200,000 euros.
palmade Pierre Palmade trial of Pierre Palmade justice
