The controversy surrounding the Western Guiana Power Plant (CEOG) is deeply rooted in the tensions between industrial development and the preservation of the rights of indigenous communities. Located just two kilometers from the Native American village of Prospérité, the plant raises serious concerns among residents of the Kali’na ethnic group. They fear that the proximity of the installation will disrupt their traditional way of life, threaten their natural environment and be established without an adequate consultation process. Indigenous peoples highlight a lack of communication and engagement, alleging that no free, prior and informed consent was obtained before the project was approved, a potential violation of international agreements to which France is a party.
International Reactions and Pressures
The intervention of the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (Cerd), following a complaint filed by leaders of the Kali’na community, marks a significant step in the fight against the project. The Committee expressed concern about the lack of consultation with the Kali’na people and the negative impact of the project on their lands and lives. Additionally, the Cerd letter mentions disturbing reports of excessive use of force by French authorities, detentions and legal proceedings against members of the community, which could escalate tensions and harm the international reputation of France
Local Implications and Challenges
On the ground, resistance to the construction of the power plant is manifested through protests and legal actions led by Prospérité residents. The traditional village chief, supported by local and international organizations, is calling for a complete reassessment of the project, insisting that the plant be relocated or that its development be suspended until a consensual agreement is obtained. These actions highlight the gap often observed between energy development plans and the imperatives of respect for human and environmental rights.
Ecological and Social Consequences
The CEOG project, although ambitious in its quest to provide renewable energy to around 10,000 homes through innovative hydrogen-based technology, cannot ignore its ecological implications. The construction of such infrastructure in an area rich in biodiversity could lead to major ecological disruptions, affecting local fauna and flora as well as water resources. The challenge is therefore to find a balance between technological advances and ecological conservation, a balance still far from being achieved in this project. The case of the photovoltaic power plant in French Guiana is a poignant example of the challenges that renewable energy projects encounter when they are implemented in sensitive contexts. It highlights the need for planning that fully incorporates the rights and voices of local communities, ensuring that technological progress does not come at the expense of indigenous people and the environment.
#French
