“I love you neither”: the “rankings” of universities, these controversial but hyper-scrutinized rankings

“I love you neither”: the “rankings” of universities, these controversial but hyper-scrutinized rankings
“I love you neither”: the “rankings” of universities, these controversial but hyper-scrutinized rankings

Published on September 30, 2024 at 05:33. / Modified on September 30, 2024 at 10:20.

It has become a tradition since the first publication of the ranking of Shanghai in 2003: every year during the summer, the academic world – and the press – monitors the results of Swiss universities in international comparison. 2024 was no exception: “Shanghai ranking: several Swiss universities in the Top 100”, “Shanghai ranking: Unige in 58th place”, “Shanghai ranking: unbeatable American universities, 5 Swiss universities in the Top 100,” headlined the local press in mid-August. A few weeks later, the figures will be proudly repeated in the auditoriums to welcome the new students. It will be a question of prestige, heritage, scientific excellence.

But if they guarantee good publicity, the rankings are however debated, in particular due to the commercial interests of certain suppliers of said rankings, a lack of transparency in the methodologies and the “promotion of a single form of model of excellence”, details the European University Association in a published report in 2023. She then underlined the fact that in order to perform, certain universities find themselves faced with the temptation to orient their policy according to the indicators evaluated – such as the reception of foreign students.

Want to read all of our articles?

For CHF 29.- per month, enjoy unlimited access to our articles, without obligation!

I subscribe

I-love-you-neither-the-rankings-of-unive
Good reasons to subscribe to Le Temps:
  • Unlimited access to all content available on the website.
  • Unlimited access to all content available on the mobile application
  • Sharing plan of 5 articles per month
  • Consultation of the digital version of the newspaper from 10 p.m. the day before
  • Access to supplements and T, the Temps magazine, in e-paper format
  • Access to a set of exclusive benefits reserved for subscribers

Already a subscriber?
Log in

-

-

PREV In Nepal, Kathmandu and its valley devastated by torrential rains
NEXT Anti-bunker bombs, intelligence… How Israel eliminated Hassan Nasrallah in Lebanon