After two stinging defeats in the Premier League, zero goals scored, and seven shipped in a debilitating start to the season Everton’s mission was clear: dispatch Doncaster Rovers from the Carabao Cup, chalk up a first win, and prepare for Bournemouth’s visit on Saturday in far better heart.
They achieved this, in a scrappy performance riven with tension until Iliman Ndiaye danced through the Rovers rearguard and pinged a cute finish in off Ian Lawlor’s right post to make it 2-0 on 74 minutes. Victory was confirmed by Beto’s late strike, and was reward for Sean Dyche after the manager fielded a strong XI including Jordan Pickford, Michael Keane and Dwight McNeil to try to do so.
This classic early-season cup meeting of top-flight giant and bottom-tier minnow had a flashpoint when Everton’s captain, Séamus Coleman, charged over to Jack Senior to inform him not to shove Jesper Lindstrøm down the Goodison Park touchline slope again. The upbraiding was followed by an alarm for the visitors when Joseph Olowu’s interception of James Garner’s threaded ball through the Rovers centre rolled past the onrushing visiting keeper, Lawlor. For a moment a comical own goal was on the cards but the Rovers No 1 recovered.
Everton were often slick in the buildup, as when Garner tapped the ball to Lindstrøm, whose run in behind splayed the red-hooped rearguard; or when manoeuvring McNeil into yards of space, though after shaping to shoot he fluffed a layoff to Beto, causing Dyche to wheel round to his bench in exasperation. McNeil pulled the trigger but did not trouble Lawlor, in what was a pattern of Everton supremacy with a frustrating end product.
Earlier, the vocal band of travelling support had greeted a rare sequence of passes from their men with mirthful chants of “Olé!” Now, they cheered a genuine near-miss as Grant McCann’s charges worked the ball to Senior. Drifting into an inside-right channel he let fly, causing Pickford to leap right to save.
The Rovers bench were oohing and Dyche was breathing heavily again and wondering why the No 23 was unmarked. It prompted the Rovers’ fans to taunt their counterparts with volleys of “That’s why you’re going down,” which followed the previous jibe aimed at their manager that he was to be sacked in the morning.
All very pantomime and which pointed, as well, to Everton’s nerviness after their dire Premier League start; this was underlined by a terrible mix-up between Vitaliy Mykolenko and Pickford that handed their foes a corner. This type of clumsiness was streaked through the home side’s play until Garner offered a flash of quality via a devilish curved cross that Beto was inches away from connecting with at point-blank range.
As the opening period ebbed away, Garner, the tie’s best performer so far, went closest: his volley from a corner smashed off Lawlor’s left post and Rovers escaped.
Jake O’Brien, in defence, Iliman Ndiaye (attack) and Tim Iroegbunam (midfield) were all given full debuts as Dyche made six changes from the 4-0 thrashing at Tottenham, the same number Doncaster showed from Saturday’s 1-0 win over Morecambe.
From this on-field cast had to come an act to break the match open or penalties would decide who was to progress: Iroegbunam-McNeil did so, when the former’s goalbound effort from outside Rovers’ area was flicked in by the latter: at least, according to the public-address announcer, who changed his initial call to award the 24-year-old the strike.
after newsletter promotion
How do I sign up for sport breaking news alerts?
Show
- Download the Guardian app from the iOS App Store on iPhone or the Google Play store on Android by searching for ‘The Guardian’.
- If you already have the Guardian app, make sure you’re on the most recent version.
- In the Guardian app, tap the Menu button at the bottom right, then go to Settings (the gear icon), then Notifications.
- Turn on sport notifications.
At 35 and with 15 years at the club Coleman is the soul of Everton and an emblem of their financially straitened current times. This vast experience means a cool head, too, as the full-back displayed when easing the replacement Kyle Hurst away from goal as he sought to burst in behind.
Soon after the Irishman was taken off to loud appreciation, moments after Beto missed with a free header from yards out. If the centre-forward had scored home heart rates would have lowered. Instead, they rocketed when Joe Sbarra floated into Everton’s area and unloaded – Pickford saved when really the England man should have been beaten.
But next came Ndiaye’s sweet solo finish and Beto’s simple tap-in.
