A promotion that is too smooth, too whiny or already on top? The unfiltered debate of our journalists!

A promotion that is too smooth, too whiny or already on top? The unfiltered debate of our journalists!
A promotion that is too smooth, too whiny or already on top? The unfiltered debate of our journalists!

In front of the Saturday evening bonuses and the daily ones on TF1, or for the most motivated in front of the live broadcast on TF1+, fans of the Star Academy are there. Launched on October 12, the headline tele-hook offers once again this year the opportunity to witness the artistic evolution of the candidates, but also to follow them in their daily lives. Three weeks after the start of the adventure, everyone now expresses their personality and feels more comfortable in the group. It is therefore time to write Tele-Leisure to take out the notebook and reveal your opinions, in complete honesty!

Star Academy 2024 : A “woo-ouin” promo?

Speedwell : Fatigue, loss of voice, tears… In less than three weeks, some candidates already seem to have reached the end of their limits. Maureen inherited Lénie's slate, Ulysse also has vocal problems on the eve of the third evaluations, when Thomas, Ebony and even Marguerite constantly question their ability on the show. After a very successful 11th season, has the level become too high?

Akhillé : It's autumn and it's raining tears! Ebony, Maureen, Marguerite, Masseo, Marine, Emma, ​​Charles, Ulysse… No need to cite the whole class, the idea is there: rare are the days on the live show or in the daily newspaper where at least one student is not a little too close to the pack of tissues. This class is obviously very sensitive, but it's time to gain character, and we can see that the complaints are starting to annoy some teachers!

Star Academy 2024 : “Let’s give them a chance”

Maé : It's hard to join fifteen candidates at the same time, we inevitably have our favorites and those we like a little less. Repeated tears tend to spoil the pleasure of everyday life, we feel that they lack maturity. But I like the very different palette of this casting which remains endearing, with a level which seems to me above previous editions. Let's see what happens over time!

Naomie : Talent-wise, the 15 candidates fully deserve their place in the Star Academy. If there is nothing to complain about on the professional side, the small downside of this season mainly concerns the immaturity of the casting which was felt from the first day: most of the candidates have barely left high school. Some students are more dissipated than others and have an unfortunate tendency to create unnecessary tension. Despite everything, the atmosphere remains good-natured and caring, like previous seasons.

Star Academy 2024 : “We’re already a fan!”

Laura : The challenge was huge: this season has already succeeded in making us forget the success of the previous one! We find the same qualities there. First, kindness, as when Maïa, having difficulty with a choreography, is helped by her comrades. But also the work, which is already worth the progress for the less experienced like Noah and Charles. Finally, faced with the 2023 vintage which is a bit too smooth, personalities are already emerging like Marguerite, who does not hesitate to reprimand her comrades for their disorder or Ebony who does not hide her ambition to reach the summits!

Agathe : Even if the level is as usual very uneven, several students in the class of 2024 have the makings of future great musicians like Franck the young man who performed until now in the Gare Saint Lazare which today seems to be his place on stage, Masséo who sings and dances and who one would think came from the Disney stables, or even Marguerite and her gently offbeat universe. We will also not fail to highlight the presence of Ebony, Julie, Ulysse and even Maureen who prove their artistic qualities every week.

-

-

PREV Hillary (The Fifty): this detail about her physical appearance that she tried to hide
NEXT Agatha All Along (Mini-series, episodes 8 and 9): end of series