There is no exact age where kids stop believing in Santa Claus. But some research suggests that it’s most common for skepticism to creep in somewhere around age 8. That’s just 8 very short years of putting out milk and cookies, leaving carrots for the reindeer, and writing letters to the Big Man. Santa is such a big part of what makes Christmas magical for kids.
Once that illusion is gone, you’re only a stone’s throw away from everyone just giving each other sweaters and gift cards. So all the parents I know are fighting tooth and nail to keep that magic alive as their children grow older, even if it’s just for one more year.
Dad Kris Tapley found he had a skeptic on his hands: His 8-year-old son. This year, he went to extraordinary lengths to keep Christmas alive.
Tapley’s son is 8, but has been a Santa skeptic for at least a few years. Though he hasn’t quite put all the pieces together yet, he’s been spotting inconsistencies and plot holes for a while now. “Reindeer can’t fly! Someone can’t go all over the world in one night! Stop lying, Daddy,” Tapley says, quoting his son.
Tapley posted on X and said this about the challenge facing him this year: “My kid has been denying Santa Claus for a few years now but I just haven’t had the heart to give in. He probably thinks I’m insane by this point. Anyway, to shut me up, he insisted on setting up a camera last night.”
In the embedded video, we see a crystal clear feed of the Tapleys’ Christmas Eve milk and cookies set up. You can even see the Christmas tree, some stockings, and a door into the room. They’ve got the whole area covered. Nowhere for Santa to hide. If he exists, they’re guaranteed to bust him! And if he doesn’t show, Tapley’s son will have his answer.
But, Tapley added, “HE DIDN’T COUNT ON DADDY’S FILM DEGREE.”
As the footage rolls, the door to the room cracks open slowly. A figure begins walking through. But then, the screen goes haywire — static! When the video feed returns, the door to the room is closing, a hand pulling it shut just visible. And now the room is filled with presents. The milk is gone. The cookies have been snacked on.
There was proof alright. Proof that Santa was real, and that his magic would prevent him from ever truly being caught.
“I think he bought it,” Tapley says.
He showed his son the footage on Christmas morning and it seemed to have the intended effect. But for how long is another question.
“He’s already poking some holes in my story. ‘Why doesn’t it cause a glitch when he’s on camera in other things?’ That kind of thing.”
Tapley’s video went viral on X, racking up over a million views. Commenters loved the commitment to the bit, and the excellent display of dadding.
“As a kid, this would have me convinced until I’m 36,” wrote one user.
“Well done! Keep the magic going,” said another.
“He’ll love you for doing [this] when he gets older,” said another.
“A+ parenting!” said another, sharing their own story: “When I started having doubts about Santa, my mom typed a letter from Santa to me, printed it on fancy paper, stamped a signature and some decorations on it and left it in my stocking. I believed in Santa for a few more years, and still have the letter somewhere.”
Of course, as the video spread even farther and wider than before, some Grinchy people chimed in with critiques: Of the deception and, weirdly enough, of the quality of the video edit. See what happens to people who lose sight of the fun and magic of make-believe at Christmas?
Photo by Srikanta H. U on Unsplash
It’s really a tremendously sad day for parents when their kids no longer believe. Playing Santa and keeping the illusion going is fun for us and helps keep us young. Christmas will always be about spending time with the people you love, but let’s face it, it loses a little something when the element of magical make-believe goes away.
Tapley knows he doesn’t have much time left with his son, when it comes to Elves and the North Pole and Naughty or Nice lists. The trick video might have worked, or his son might just be playing along, but either way, he’ll take it.
“I figure I bought myself another year of maintaining some of the magic.”
