The fall tour left its mark. Humiliated by its opponents and weakened by questionable choices, the XV de la Rose approaches the Six Nations Tournament in a precarious position. With just two months to go before kick-off, Steve Borthwick and his team must face a reality: everything has to be rebuilt. The Guardian recently highlighted the glaring lack of progress and the many structural issues holding the team back.
A disastrous fall tour
The latest success against Japan was not enough to hide the shortcomings. In defense, the system nicknamed “The Hammer” showed its limits. Jamie George, captain of the team, believes that progress is still far from enough. Offensively, despite some flashes orchestrated by Marcus Smith, the initiatives lack coherence.
Even more worrying, the English team seems to suffer from a physical and athletic deficit. Against the world's top teams, England were dominated in the duels and unable to impose their rhythm. These performances cast doubt on its ability to turn things around in time.
The causes of a worrying decline
Too rigid a selection
The RFU's policy, prohibiting the selection of players playing abroad, is increasingly criticized. Talents like Jack Willis or Joe Marchantwho shine outside the borders, could fill the team's current gaps. However, these players remain inaccessible to Borthwick, which considerably limits his options.
Unsuitable tactical plans
England's game has become too predictable. The players seem locked into rigid instructions, preventing any creativity or spontaneity. Several experts call for freeing the game to allow explosive profiles like Gabriel Ibitoye or Alex Mitchell to express themselves fully. But for this, a real strategic overhaul is necessary.
A leadership problem
At 34 years old, Jamie George still plays the captain of the XV de la Rose, but for how long? The absence of a succession plan is worrying. Figures like Ellis Genge or Ollie Chessum could become the new leaders, but they still need to be offered a real place within the project.
Emergencies to be dealt with before the Tournament
Reorganize the defense
The current defensive system, based on an aggressive build-up, has proven ineffective. Too risky, it exposes the team to gaping holes. The staff must rethink this strategy to make it more adapted to the qualities of the players available.
Bridging physical gaps
The departure of Aled Walters, renowned physical trainer, left a void in the staff. The team suffered from a lack of physical preparation, particularly visible at the end of the match. Finding a competent replacement is a top priority for the coming months.
Rekindle group dynamics
To hope to compete in the Six Nations, the staff must strengthen cohesion. Players, often split between several clubs, must find unity. More intense collective preparation could be the key to fielding a united team ready to fight.
Ireland, a ruthless first test
The schedule does not work in England's favor: its first match will see it face Ireland in Dublin, the world number one team. This shock could be a fatal blow for Borthwick in the event of a rout. However, an achievement at the Aviva Stadium could also mark a turning point and give hope to supporters.
Time is running out for the XV de la Rose. The work is huge, and the Six Nations are fast approaching. A reaction is expected, but the task promises to be titanic. For Steve Borthwick and his team, it is now a matter of saving what can be saved.
I grew up in a family where rugby was at all times. I was at the edge of the pitch when Castres beat Pau and joined the elite, I was in the Stade Pierre Antoine facing Gary Whetton when he did his Haka to celebrate the Brennus of 1993 and I was always rocked legends of this sport. Now, it is with XV Ovalie that I intend to extend the adventure. #TeamCO
