Since his arrival behind the bench of the Montreal Canadiens, Martin St-Louis has been praised, criticized, but rarely ignored.
However, for the first time since he took the reins of the Habs, his status is seriously contested.
Fans and pundits, frustrated by the team’s inconsistent performance, are wondering whether the Martin St. Louis experiment should continue.
Faced with this rise in criticism, a voice rose to defend it, that of 98.5 FM, the most listened to radio station in Quebec.
Following the Canadiens’ difficult 4-3 victory against the Columbus Blue Jackets, Dany Dubé and Mario Langlois took positions.
With passion and conviction, they reminded listeners that St. Louis must be given the time and tools necessary to prove itself.
Mario Langlois was angry:
“Let Martin St-Louis work! »
For Langlois, the debate around St-Louis is tinged with emotion, often amplified by the excessive expectations of Montreal supporters.
It invites more calm and measured reflection, reminding us that reconstruction is a long process fraught with pitfalls.
Dany Dubé added his two cents by evoking a striking parallel:
“I’m going to tell you about Alain Vigneault. I tell people: be careful with your impatience, because your impatience is tied to emotion. »
Alain Vigneault had been fired from Montreal, but he had no team in front of him. He has become one of the best head coaches in the entire NHL.
Dubé stressed that even a talented coach is limited by the quality of his squad. According to him, it would be unfair to point the finger at St-Louis while the team is still rebuilding:
“Let things go, because the coach is only as good as what he has in front of him. If he had a good team that wasn’t performing well, we might have a different discussion. »
This passionate defense of St-Louis is a first in CH history. Previous coaches, notably Dominique Ducharme, Michel Therrien and Claude Julien, never benefited from such indulgence.
Dany Dubé was on the verge of losing his calm. Usually calm and reserved, he is really tired of people attacking Martin St-Louis.
Therrien, often criticized for each of his mistakes, always had to fight against the high expectations of fans and the media, without the safety net that St-Louis enjoys today.
Therrien’s resentment towards St-Louis finds a clear explanation here. St-Louis, a novice in terms of coaching, is paradoxically the most protected coach in the recent history of CH.
This immunity, whether due to his aura as a player or to the context of reconstruction, frustrates to the highest degree those who, like Therrien, had to face merciless criticism from their first day.
At 98.5 FM, the call for patience is omnipresent. According to Langlois and Dubé, it would be premature to draw conclusions about the work of St-Louis, especially in the current context of a team in transition.
They insist that judging a coach solely on immediate results, without considering structural challenges, is wrong.
For them, the problem is not St. Louis, but the lack of experience and depth of the squad.
They remind us that young players, like Juraj Slafkovsky, need time to flourish. Only once these foundations are solid can the true impact of St. Louis be assessed.
This cry from the heart from 98.5 FM resonated with some supporters, but it did not appease everyone.
On social networks, criticism continues to flow. Many wonder if St-Louis is really the man for the job or simply a symbol of the “soft” approach of the current organization.
It seems like St. Louis can do anything, and no one will hold it against them. If it was Michel Therrien or Claude Julien, they would already be outside!
Dany Dubé is right, but how much longer will we wait before seeing progress?
The debate around Martin St-Louis illustrates how high expectations are in Montreal, even during a period of reconstruction.
98.5 FM has taken a strong stand, but their plea raises a fundamental question: How much patience does supporters have?
For the moment, St-Louis can count on the support of part of the media and, it seems, of its organization. But as Mario Langlois recalled,
“Let Martin St-Louis work! »
It remains to be seen whether this national message will be enough to calm the storm. Because in Montreal, patience has always been a rare virtue.
Dany Dubé was really pumped up. An intensity and rare anger reminding everyone that the coach is not the real problem with this team in difficulty.
For Dubé, blaming the coach for the failures amounts to ignoring the true nature of the reconstruction undertaken by the Canadian.
But this defense also raises troubling questions: How much longer can we hide behind the excuse of reconstruction?
While Dubé and Mario Langlois advocate patience, many observers and supporters are starting to lose hope. Canadians are not only showing signs of stagnation: they are giving the impression of regressing.
Even with an overtime win against Columbus, St. Louis’ face at the press conference spoke volumes.
Withdrawn, surrounded, with a pale complexion, he seemed almost relieved, but not happy. This image, which marked the media and supporters, has become a symbol of the malaise that inhabits this organization.
St. Louis seems to be carrying the weight of reconstruction alone, and the results are not there to lighten this burden.
On social networks, criticism is becoming more and more virulent:
“Where is the progress of young people?”
“What’s the point of this game system if no one understands it?”
“Martin St-Louis spends more time finding excuses than finding solutions.”
The comments are ruthless, and even the most patient supporters are beginning to doubt. What seemed like a daring experiment – handing over the keys to the locker room to an inexperienced coach – is now seen by many as a costly mistake.
Martin St-Louis has always advocated an approach based on patience and development. But the facts are there: Juraj Slafkovsky is struggling to find his bearings, Kirby Dach seems lost, and the team continues to accumulate defensive errors.
Quebec supporters, passionate and demanding, are not asking for immediate victories. They want to see a clear plan, a progression that can be seen, that can be felt.
For them, the optimistic speech from St. Louis is starting to look like a smokescreen, a way to buy time in a reconstruction that seems to drag on without real direction.
Dany Dubé’s heartfelt cry on 98.5 FM touched several listeners, but it was not enough to appease the anger of the majority.
If Dubé and Langlois still believe in the potential of St-Louis, the fans are starting to seriously question: is Martin St-Louis the man for the job?
The anger of 98.5 FM is practically “cute”, but in a market like Montreal, it has its limits. And these limits now seem to have been reached.
The unfailing support of certain media, such as 98.5 FM, proves a disturbing reality: Martin St-Louis is the most protected coach in recent Canadiens history.
Unlike Michel Therrien, dismissed despite clearly superior performances, St-Louis seems to benefit from an immunity which is starting to annoy some fans.
Perhaps this is due to his legendary status as a player. Perhaps it is because of the reconstruction, which still serves as a shield for its disappointing results.
But one thing is certain: this immunity will not last forever. And if St-Louis fails to reverse the trend, even the anger of Dany Dubé and Mario Langlois will not be able to protect it from the growing anger of “Quebec hockey”.
