Stormy Daniels affair | Judge rejects overturning of Trump’s conviction based on presidential immunity

(New York) Donald Trump lost a round on Monday in his battle to overturn his only criminal conviction, for hidden payments to porn actress Stormy Daniels, with the New York judge rejecting his appeal on the basis of immunity presidential.

Donald Trump’s lawyers invoked the presumption of criminal immunity recognized on 1^is July to the President of the United States by the Supreme Court to request the annulment of the judgment rendered against him on May 30.

They argued that part of the evidence and testimony against him should not have been presented at trial, because it fell within his “official acts”, under this later judgment.

But Judge Juan Merchan concluded in his decision that the acts in question had no official character and were therefore not covered by presidential immunity.

He adds that even if incriminating evidence was wrongly used, it did not weigh “in the face of the overwhelming evidence of guilt” of the accused.

Donald Trump was convicted in this case of “aggravated accounting falsification to conceal a conspiracy to pervert the 2016 election”, but his sentencing has been postponed several times.

Following his victory in the November 5 vote, his lawyers presented a new appeal, invoking his status as president-designate, incompatible according to them with the verdict.

Judge Merchan sought submissions from both parties on the matter earlier this month, but has not yet ruled on the appeal.

The prosecution opposes an outright annulment, but says it is willing to make “arrangements” so that the criminal proceedings do not “weigh” on the second Trump presidency.

The Manhattan prosecutor, Alvin Bragg, therefore proposed to the judge not to sentence Donald Trump to a “term of incarceration” or that “the procedure be suspended during the presidential term” of four years, i.e. until January 2029.

Unprecedented situation

The case concerns hidden payments of $130,000, before the 2016 presidential election, to a pornographic film actress, Stormy Daniels, so that she would keep quiet about a sexual encounter ten years earlier. A relationship that Mr. Trump has always denied.

Of the four criminal proceedings targeting Donald Trump, this case is the only one in which a trial was held for the candidate in the presidential election which he won, an unprecedented scenario in American history.

Special prosecutor Jack Smith recommended and obtained in late November a halt to federal charges against him for illegal attempts to overturn the results of the 2020 election, and for withholding classified documents after his departure from the White House.

After consultations, the Department of Justice concluded that its policy since the Watergate scandal in 1973, consisting of not prosecuting a sitting president, “applies to this unprecedented situation,” explained Jack Smith.

This conclusion “does not depend on the seriousness of the crimes concerned, the strength of the prosecution’s case or the merits of the prosecution”, he clarified.

As for Georgia, where Donald Trump is charged with 14 other people with similar acts of electoral interference in 2020, his lawyer asked the courts of this state to declare themselves incompetent to judge the man who “is now the president-elect and soon the 47^e President of the United States.”