Criticisms of the UJFP on the remarks of Minister Jean-Noël Barrot

The French Jewish Union for Peace (UJFP) recently demanded the resignation of the French Minister of Diplomacy, Jean-Noël Barrot. This request follows the minister’s controversial statements during a debate in the National Assembly on November 12.

Jean-Noël Barrot had affirmed that “the repeated accusation of war crimes against Israel constitutes a systematic attempt to trivialize the Shoah”. The UJFP considered these remarks deeply offensive to the memory of the victims of genocides. According to the organization, they “deny the seriousness of the crimes committed against the Palestinian people”, and this rhetoric is described as “denialist and anti-Semitic” in their press release.

The UJFP also criticizes the conflation of criticism of Israel’s policies with anti-Semitism, emphasizing that these comments distract from human rights violations in Palestine. The organization goes so far as to declare that the minister “has dishonored his office” and calls for his “immediate resignation”.

Faced with this situation, the UJFP calls for citizen mobilization to denounce these comments, urging the political class to take responsibility to avoid such “excesses”. The current tense climate around the Palestinian question and memorial speeches is relaunching the debate on ethics in politics.

This affair echoes a similar controversy that occurred in January, when the former Minister of Foreign Affairs, Stéphane Séjourné, caused controversy with his statements to the National Assembly. At the time, Jean-Christophe Lemoine, deputy spokesperson for the Quai d’Orsay, invoked the historical past of the Shoah to justify Séjourné’s remarks, but also recognized that “the forced transfer of populations” was a serious violation of international law.

Furthermore, persistent tensions in the Middle East have been worsening since a Hamas attack in October 2023, which led Israel to continue its military actions in Gaza despite a call from the United Nations Security Council for a ceasefire. . More than 43,700 people have been killed, mostly civilians, and shortages of essential resources are severely affecting the region.