“The worst I've seen this year” This controversial film is TOP 2 on Netflix: the first opinions are salty!

News culture “The worst I've seen this year” This controversial film is TOP 2 on Netflix: the first opinions are salty!

Sweet Jesus…

A few weeks before its release on Netflix, DJ Caruso revealed his intentions to present a complex and determined Marie, fighting against prejudice, persecution and her exceptional destiny. The emphasis placed on this inner journey, as well as the first encouraging images, had given us a glimpse of an original and profound portrait.

Here is how the film was presented by its director:

Marie was an intelligent and determined young woman who faced monumental challenges: overcoming social stigma, escaping a jealous king, and bearing the weight of a destiny that would change the world. Although she had fears and doubts, her courage and faith pushed her to accept her divine purpose. This film highlights this journey. This film highlights Mary's journey, blending sacred scriptures to create a story that is both sacred and modern. It's an approach that transcends genres and (…) if you're not religious, the film offers strong moments with action and striking images, all in a dangerous geopolitical landscape.

After achievements in the action genre, DJ Caruso tried to seduce the public with an ambitious biblical fresco. Marie, worn by Noa Cohen and Anthony Hopkins, promised an explosive mix of spectacle and reflection. Unfortunately, the bet seems lost according to the first reactions. The story opens with the story of Anne and Joachim, a couple imploring God to have a child. We then follow the birth and her evolution of Mary, until the moment she is taken to the Temple.

So let's be clear, the critics are not kind at all to the film!

Critics who do not rise to seventh heaven

Collider explains that the script by Timothy Michael Hayes, too immature, and the many liberties taken with the biblical story harm the overall quality of the film. Despite a talented cast, the ensemble lacks depth and fails to offer an original vision of Marie's life. FandomeWire adds that for those looking for Christmas thrills, this film offers a more exciting alternative. Nevertheless, its main objective remains to nourish the viewer's faith rather than to question it.

The Telegraph is clear, this biblical biopic from Netflix is ​​undoubtedly the worst film of the year. A disastrous choice at all levels, from production to interpretation, including a more than doubtful scenario.

Neither Netflix nor director DJ Caruso come out winners from this adaptation of Marie's life. The critics are unanimous: the film is a dismal failure… As a reminder, the film has been available on the SVOD Netflix platform since December 6, 2024.