Going from student to winner then to teacher during evaluations is Pierre Garnier's journey in less than a year, thanks to Star Academy. The young singer who has enjoyed dazzling success for a year was back at the Château de Dammarie-les-Lys to assist the teachers during the evaluations.
A special role for a particular week: that of the tour. The evaluations which took place yesterday, Tuesday morning, not without a touch of stress because everyone dreams of participating in the tour and touching this dream of becoming an artist more than ever.
The exceptional teacher disagrees with the director
While many Internet users followed the evaluations live thanks to the live broadcast of TF1 +, other images were also shown in the daily newspaper of this Wednesday, November 27. And in particular the reactions of the teachers after the students' performances. During a short debriefing, Pierre Garnier did not hesitate to tell Michael Goldman, director, what he thought. In this case, he did not agree with him.
To defend his place, Charles performed SOS from an earthling in distress. But Michael Goldman was not convinced by the staging. “The positive point is that vocally it's exceptional but the staging, there was certainly one, but I found it almost parasitic. I would have liked him to do it alone behind the microphone and I 'I have the impression that the performance would have been better'said the director. “I don’t really agree!”launched Pierre Garnier. Before continuing: “JI think the scenography was magnificent, I find it very prettyit's just that it was perhaps not connected enough, as you said, in the interpretation. And I think that if he was really there, the scenography would have been a plus. I found it great, really incredible.” concluded the interpreter of Those we werecrowned song of the year at the NRJ Music Awards on November 1st.
Michael Goldman too harsh? Pierre Garnier confirms
Subsequently, it is towards Maureen and her performance on Dalida's song, I want to die on stage, that the son of Jean-Jacques Goldman was critical. It still didn't really blow my mind, it didn't upset me but so I couldn't say that it's an extraordinary evaluation“, before being interrupted by theater professor Hugues Hamelynck: “Oh you're tough!” he said, which was confirmed by Pierre Garnier.
“It's clear, I agree”declared Héléna Bailly’s comradebefore defending the young woman: “Me, I actually took a huge beating. I found it incredible. I go to a piano bar, something like that but I stay for three hours listening to it.”
